How can you tell if a book is scholarly?
The fastest way is to check the publisher- if it's published by a university press (e.g. Chicago, Harvard, etc.) or other academic presses (e.g., Blackwell, Routledge, Palgrave, Ashgate) it is scholarly. Another way to decide is to look at the book's intended audience and purpose.
How are scholarly books different from regular books?
Scholarly books are published with the goal of contributing to research and knowledge of a subject, and support future research by scholars and students, not necessarily making money.
Who decides whether or not a scholarly book gets published?
All scholarly books go through an extensive process in which experts in the field read the manuscripts and decide if the book is worthy to be published. In other words, scholarly books are peer reviewed sources.
Remember, scholarly books are just one of many kinds of books available through the library. If you are unsure if the book you have found is scholarly ask a librarian or your professor.
Empirical articles are those in which authors report on their own study. The authors will have collected data to answer a research question. Empirical research contains observed and measured examples that inform or answer the research question. The data can be collected in a variety of ways such as interviews, surveys, questionnaires, observations, and various other quantitative and qualitative research methods.
Various phrases or keywords can identify articles that use empirical or qualitative research. These include:
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
PURPOSE OF A LIT REVIEW
A literature summarizes & analyzes published work on a topic in order to
WHAT DOES A LIT REVIEW LOOK LIKE?
The format is usually a bibliographic essay; sources are briefly cited within the body of the essay, with full bibliographic citations at the end.
The introduction should define the topic and set the context for the literature review. It will include the author's perspective or point of view on the topic, how they have defined the scope of the topic (including what's not included), and how the review will be organized. It can point out overall trends, conflicts in methodology or conclusions, and gaps in the research.
The body of the review should organize the research into major topics and subtopics. These groupings may be by subject, (e.g., globalization of clothing manufacturing), type of research (e.g., case studies), methodology (e.g., qualitative), genre, chronology, or other common characteristics. Within these groups the author can then discuss the merits of each article and provide analysis and comparison of the importance of each article to similar ones.
The conclusion will summarize the main findings, make clear how this review of the literature supports (or not) the research to follow, and may point the direction for further research.
The list of references will include full citations for all of the items mentioned in the lit review.
A theoretical article contains or refers to new or established abstract principles related to a specific field of knowledge. These article are peer reviewed but do not normally contain research or present experimental data.
Look for terms like concepts, conceptual, framework, model, theoretical foundation, and perspectives.
Scholarly journals will publish some types of articles that are not peer reviewed or based on research.
Remember that not every article in peer-reviewed journals is a peer-reviewed research article.
Editorials: Often times the editor of a journal will write an article with his or opinion or summary of the article. This can lead you to good sources but are not appropriate for most research papers.
Empirical articles are those in which authors report on their own study. The authors will have collected data to answer a research question. Empirical research contains observed and measured examples that inform or answer the research question. The data can be collected in a variety of ways such as interviews, surveys, questionnaires, observations, and various other quantitative and qualitative research methods.
|
Section |
Definition |
|
Abstract |
A short synopsis of the article’s content |
|
Introduction |
Need and rational of this particular research project with research question, statement, and hypothesis. |
|
Literature Review (sometimes included in the Introduction) |
Supporting their ideas with other scholarly research |
|
Methods |
Describes the methodology including a description of the participants, and a description of the research method, measure, research design, or approach to data analysis. |
|
Results or Findings |
Uses narrative, charts, tables, graphs, or other graphics to describe the findings of the paper |
|
Discussion/Conclusion/Implications |
Provides a discussion, summary, or conclusion, bringing together the research question, statement, |
|
References |
References all the articles discussed and cited in the paper- mostly in the literature or results sections |